发送 stderr/stdout 消息到函数并捕获退出信号

Question

我正在处理错误并登录我的 bash 脚本。下面我包含了一个简化的代码 sn-p 来举例说明用例。

我想在我的脚本中实现以下目标：

1. 陷阱退出信号应该触发下面代码中的 onexit() 函数
2. stderr 和 stdout 应该被发送到 log() 函数，该函数将确保根据特定的日志格式将输出记录到日志文件中（在下面的示例中进行了简化）

以下当前代码存在问题：

• 步骤 1 未被 onexit 函数捕获，脚本继续执行步骤 2。很可能是因为 stderr 通过管道传输到 logStd()。如何向 logStd() 发送错误消息，但仍然在 onexit() 中捕获退出信号？

分辨率：

1. 添加set -o pipefail
2. 通过添加local exit_status=${1:-$?} 获取onexit() 的退出状态

script.sh（解决后编辑）

#!/bin/bash -E
set -o pipefail

# Perform program exit housekeeping
function onexit {
    local exit_status=${1:-$?}
    log "onexit() called with param: $exit_status"
    exit $1
}

# Simplified log function that sends input parameter to echo. This function is used within this script
# In real case this function would send log statement to log file according to specific log format
function log {
    echo "log(): $1"
}

# Simplified log function that reads input stream and sends to log
# This function is used from commands
function logStd {
    log "logStd() called"
    while IFS= read -r line; do log "$line"; done
}

# http://linuxcommand.org/wss0160.php
# The trap command allows you to execute a command when a signal is received by your script.
# Usage: trap arg signals
# "signals" is a list of signals to intercept and "arg" is a command to execute when one of the signals is received
# arg can either be a command or a function name like clean_up below
trap onexit 1 2 3 15 ERR

# STEP 1 - should fail, send errors to logstd() and be trapped by onexit()
log "**Tarballing should fail, file doesn´t exist"
tar -czf /Users/ismar.slomic/shellscripting/unknownfile.txt.gz /Users/ismar.slomic/shellscripting/unknownfile.txt 2>&1 | logStd

# STEP 2 - should run successfully and send "tar: Removing leading '/' from member names" to logStd()
log "**Tarballing should run successfully"
tar -czf /Users/ismar.slomic/shellscripting/file.txt.gz /Users/ismar.slomic/shellscripting/file.txt 2>&1 | logStd

onexit

输出：

log(): **Tarballing should fail, file doesn´t exist
log(): logStd() called
log(): tar: /Users/ismar.slomic/shellscripting/unknownfile.txt: Cannot stat:  No such file or directory
log(): tar: Error exit delayed from previous errors.
log(): **Tarballing should run successfully
log(): logStd() called
log(): tar: Removing leading '/' from member names
log(): onexit() called with param:

Answer 1

你必须使用

set -o pipefail

看到这个related StackOverflow Question。

---

小例子：

#!/bin/bash

trap handler ERR
handler() { echo trapped ; }

echo 1
false | :

echo 2
set -o pipefail
false | :

输出：

$ bash test.sh
1
2
trapped