首先，直接回答你的问题：
您的功能运行良好，我在本地对其进行了测试。我尝试了水平和垂直，x 和 o。一定是你对调用者做的事情。
这段代码最大的问题是清晰度。通过将逻辑分成组，您可以在清晰度方面做很多事情。
可以通过制作特定于应用程序的对象来实现清晰度。
如果您有一个对象来表示移动、游戏和标记...您可以大大简化您的代码，最重要的是使其易于阅读和调试。
我继续实施井字游戏只是为了解释清楚我的意思。
任何时候你开始有大量的 if else 链和块返回语句，你可能需要花费额外的时间来解决问题。
这是完全可编译的，我认为如果你调试几次你会发现发现错误要容易得多。
调整游戏也很容易...现在，我们有 2 名玩家和 3 x 3 游戏。
但是，我们有额外的构造函数来调整游戏的大小，并为游戏玩家提供一些他们想要的井字游戏外观的选项。
这样做的主要原因是为了清晰和调试。
如果您有特定于问题的方法和特定于问题的对象，总是更容易找到问题。
下面是一个完全可编译的井字游戏控制台应用程序。在目前的形式下，它会玩 100 场随机 3 x 3 游戏并打印所有 100 场游戏的结果。
该应用程序还能够将您的字符串输入作为控制台输入并处理移动。
请注意，我们仍在使用二维数组，但我们通过将数组封装在 Board 对象中来隐藏使用它们的复杂性。
我们还提供了一个移动对象，以便我们可以存储移动以供以后播放。这在创建循环以玩许多游戏时很有用，因为有关移动的所有事实都包含在单个对象中。
因为我们创建了三个单独的方法来验证移动输入。我们对验证的内容和验证的原因有了更清晰的解释。
大多数调试器也会显示对象 toString 方法，因此通过将游戏显示嵌入到 toString() 中，我们可以在调试时查看板的外观。
编写不需要大量 cmets 的干净代码的诀窍是尝试将任何复杂性分解到自己的单元中。
稍后您可能会介绍更多有关工作单元的内容，但请记住，方法越简单，它的可重用性就越高。一个类的目的越单一，它就越好越清晰。
我的例子：
Mark.java
-这个枚举是玩家用来表示他们移动的标记的表示。
public enum Mark{
X, Y;
}
井字游戏.java
-这个类是你的主类
它负责收集用户输入、清理、处理并将输出显示给用户
请注意，除了主要方法之外，我没有在其他任何地方进行游戏显示。这使所有显示问题都集中在一个位置。将代码分解为特定对象的好处是知道在出现问题时在哪里修复。
package com.clinkworks.example;
import java.util.ArrayList;
import java.util.Collections;
import java.util.HashMap;
import java.util.List;
import java.util.Map;
import com.clinkworks.example.Move;
import com.clinkworks.example.Board;
import com.clinkworks.example.Mark;
public class TicTacToe {
//this variable is simply used for output. Since we cant save CAT in the mark enum, we
// use it to hold cats games.
private static final String catsGameIdentity = "CAT";
//this map contains the counts of wins for each symbol
//it also keeps track of ties and stores it in the map as "CAT"
//soo.. gamesToWinsMap.get("CAT") will produce the amount of ties.
private static final Map<String, Integer> gamesToWinsMap = new HashMap<String, Integer>();
public static void main(String[] args){
String game = args[0].toUpperCase(); //better ways to do this and no validation here.. but it will work
Board board = new Board();
//holds our current place in the string passed in from teh console
int currentStringLocation = 0;
for(int row = 0; row < 3; row++){ //loop through the rows
for(int column = 0; column < 3; column++){ //for each row loop through the columns
if(gameOver(board)){ // we don't care about the rest of the input if the game was won
break;
}
//convert the symbol to a string for use in teh ValueOf function in the enum class
String symbol = "" + game.charAt(currentStringLocation); //better than String.valueOf imho
//allow spaces to represent un marked places
if(" ".equals(symbol)){
currentStringLocation++; //this accounts for spaces in our input
break;
}
//convert the string to a Mark enum... over use of strings is a very very bad practice
Mark nextMarkToPlace = Mark.valueOf(symbol);
Move move = new Move(row, column, nextMarkToPlace); //we create a move object that encapsulates the complexity of placing the mark on the game board
board.play(move); //the game already knows how to play itself, just let it
currentStringLocation++; //increment the posision.
}
}
//since you may not have won the game, or gave a complete string for a cats game,
// lets at least display the board for debugging reasons.
if(board.movesLeft() > 0){
System.out.println("Board isn't finished, but here is what it looks like basd on your input: ");
System.out.println(board);
}
}
//call me main if you want to see what I do
public static void main2(String[] args) {
//lets play 100 games and see the wins and ties
playGames(100);
System.out.println("Number wins by X: " + gamesToWinsMap.get(Mark.X.name()));
System.out.println("Number wins by O: " + gamesToWinsMap.get(Mark.O.name()));
System.out.println("Number of ties: " + gamesToWinsMap.get(catsGameIdentity));
}
public static void playGames(int count) {
//play a new game each iteration, in our example, count = 100;
for (int i = 0; i < count; i++) {
playGame();
}
}
public static void playGame() {
//create a new game board. this initalizes our 2d array and lets the complexity of handling that
// array be deligated to the board object.
Board board = new Board();
//we are going to generate a random list of moves. Heres where we are goign to store it
List<Move> moves = new ArrayList<Move>();
//we are creating moves for each space on the board.
for (int row = 0; row < 3; row++) {
for (int col = 0; col < 3; col++) {
moves.add(new Move(row, col));
}
}
//randomize the move list
Collections.shuffle(moves);
//do each move
for (Move move : moves) {
board.play(move);
if(gameOver(board)){
break;
}
}
}
public static boolean gameOver(Board board){
if (board.whoWon() != null) {
System.out.println("Player with the mark: " + board.whoWon() + " won the game!");
System.out.println(board);
Integer winCount = gamesToWinsMap.get(board.whoWon().name());
winCount = winCount == null ? 1 : winCount + 1;
gamesToWinsMap.put(board.whoWon().name(), winCount);
return true;
} else if (board.movesLeft() == 0) {
System.out.println("It was a cats game!!");
System.out.println(board);
Integer catCount = gamesToWinsMap.get(catsGameIdentity);
catCount = catCount == null ? 1 : catCount + 1;
gamesToWinsMap.put(catsGameIdentity, catCount);
return true;
}
return false;
}
Move.java
-这个类负责确保只有整数被传递给游戏板
并告诉游戏板谁在移动（可选）
package com.clinkworks.example;
import com.clinkworks.example.Mark;
public class Move {
private int row;
private int column;
private Mark forcedMark;
public Move(int row, int column) {
this.row = row;
this.column = column;
}
//the board already knows who should be next. only use this constructor to override
// what symbol to put on the game board
public Move(int row, int column, Mark markToPlace){
this.row = row;
this.column = column;
forcedMark = markToPlace;
}
public int getRow() {
return row;
}
public int getColumn() {
return column;
}
public Mark getMark(){
return forcedMark;
}
}
Board.java
-这是管理所有棋盘状态的地方，谁是下一个玩家，谁赢了，以及
有没有什么动作可以玩。它还确保只玩有效的动作。
package com.clinkworks.example;
import com.clinkworks.example.Mark;
import com.clinkworks.example.Move;
public class Board {
private final int rowSize;
private final int columnSize;
private final Mark[][] gameBoard;
private Mark currentMark;
private Mark winningMark;
/**
* This constructor defaults the starting player to X with a 3 by 3
* game.
*/
public Board() {
gameBoard = new Mark[3][3];
currentMark = Mark.X; // X always goes first ;P
winningMark = null;
this.rowSize = 3;
this.columnSize = 3;
}
/**
* This constructor defaults the starting player to X, and lets the
* board size be adjusted
*/
public Board(int rowSize, int columnSize) {
gameBoard = new Mark[rowSize][columnSize];
currentMark = Mark.X; // X always goes first ;P
winningMark = null;
this.rowSize = getRowSize();
this.columnSize = columnSize;
}
/**
* this constructor allows the players to choose who goes first on a 3
* by 3 board.
*
* @param firstPlayer
*/
public Board(Mark firstPlayer) {
gameBoard = new Mark[3][3];
currentMark = firstPlayer; // Let the player choose
winningMark = null;
rowSize = 3;
columnSize = 3;
}
/**
* this constructor allows the players to choose who goes first and to
* choose the size of the board.
*
* @param firstPlayer
*/
public Board(Mark firstPlayer, int rowSize, int columnSize) {
gameBoard = new Mark[getRowSize()][columnSize];
currentMark = firstPlayer; // Let the player choose
winningMark = null;
this.rowSize = rowSize;
this.columnSize = columnSize;
}
/**
*
* @return the amount of empty spaces remaining on the game board, or if theres a winning player, zero.
*/
public int movesLeft() {
if(whoWon() != null){
return 0;
}
int moveCount = 0;
for (int x = 0; x < getRowSize(); x++) {
for (int y = 0; y < getColumnSize(); y++) {
moveCount += getMarkAt(x, y) == null ? 1 : 0;
}
}
return moveCount;
}
/**
* If someone won, this will return the winning player.
*
* @return the winning player
*/
public Mark whoWon() {
return winningMark;
}
/**
* This move allows the next player to choose where to place their mark.
* if a move is played without a player given, it will use the current player variable
*
* as a side affect, the next player in rotation is chosen.
*
* @param Move
* @return if the game is over, play will return true, otherwise false.
*/
public boolean play(Move move) {
if (!validMove(move)) {
// always fail early
throw new IllegalStateException("Cannot play " + currentMark + " at " + move.getRow() + ", " + move.getColumn() + "\n" + toString());
}
doMove(move);
boolean playerWon = isWinningMove(move);
if (playerWon) {
winningMark = currentMark;
return true;
}
togglePlayer();
boolean outOfMoves = movesLeft() <= 0;
return outOfMoves;
}
public Mark lastMarkPlayed() {
return currentMark;
}
public int getRowSize() {
return rowSize;
}
public int getColumnSize() {
return columnSize;
}
public Mark getCurrentPlayer() {
return currentMark;
}
public Mark getMarkAt(int row, int column) {
return gameBoard[row][column];
}
private void doMove(Move move) {
if(move.getMark() != null){
currentMark = move.getMark();
}
gameBoard[move.getRow()][move.getColumn()] = getCurrentPlayer();
}
private void togglePlayer() {
if (currentMark == Mark.X) {
currentMark = Mark.O;
} else {
currentMark = Mark.X;
}
}
/**
* A valid move is a move where the row and the column are within boundries
* and no move has been made that the location specified by the move.
*/
private boolean validMove(Move move) {
boolean noMarkAtIndex = false;
boolean indexesAreOk = move.getRow() >= 0 || move.getRow() < getRowSize();
indexesAreOk = indexesAreOk && move.getColumn() >= 0 || move.getColumn() < getColumnSize();
if (indexesAreOk) {
noMarkAtIndex = getMarkAt(move.getRow(), move.getColumn()) == null;
}
return indexesAreOk && noMarkAtIndex;
}
private boolean isWinningMove(Move move) {
// since we check to see if the player won on each move
// we are safe to simply check the last move
return winsDown(move) || winsAcross(move) || winsDiagnally(move);
}
private boolean winsDown(Move move) {
boolean matchesColumn = true;
for (int i = 0; i < getColumnSize(); i++) {
Mark markOnCol = getMarkAt(move.getRow(), i);
if (markOnCol != getCurrentPlayer()) {
matchesColumn = false;
break;
}
}
return matchesColumn;
}
private boolean winsAcross(Move move) {
boolean matchesRow = true;
for (int i = 0; i < getRowSize(); i++) {
Mark markOnRow = getMarkAt(i, move.getColumn());
if (markOnRow != getCurrentPlayer()) {
matchesRow = false;
break;
}
}
return matchesRow;
}
private boolean winsDiagnally(Move move) {
// diagnals we only care about x and y being teh same...
// only perfect squares can have diagnals
// so we check (0,0)(1,1)(2,2) .. etc
boolean matchesDiagnal = false;
if (isOnDiagnal(move.getRow(), move.getColumn())) {
matchesDiagnal = true;
for (int i = 0; i < getRowSize(); i++) {
Mark markOnDiagnal = getMarkAt(i, i);
if (markOnDiagnal != getCurrentPlayer()) {
matchesDiagnal = false;
break;
}
}
}
return matchesDiagnal;
}
private boolean isOnDiagnal(int x, int y) {
if (boardIsAMagicSquare()) {
return x == y;
} else {
return false;
}
}
private boolean boardIsAMagicSquare() {
return getRowSize() == getColumnSize();
}
//prints out the board in a nice to view display
public String toString() {
StringBuffer stringBuffer = new StringBuffer();
for(int y = 0; y < getColumnSize(); y++) {
for(int x = 0; x < getRowSize(); x++) {
Mark mark = getMarkAt(x, y);
String markToPrint = "";
if (mark == null) {
markToPrint = " ";
} else {
markToPrint = mark.name();
}
stringBuffer.append("|").append(markToPrint);
}
stringBuffer.append("|\n");
}
return stringBuffer.toString();
}
}
}