我在代码中实现了@diogoriba 算法，结果如下：
- 找到前两个字符串的共同前缀，然后将其与从第 3 个开始的所有后续字符串进行比较，如果没有找到共同点，则修剪公共字符串，在前缀中的共同点多于前缀的情况下获胜不同。
- 但是，bumperbox 的原始算法（错误修正除外）在字符串前缀的共同点少于不同点的情况下胜出。 代码cmets中的详细信息！
我实现的另一个想法：
首先检查数组中最短的字符串，并将其用于比较，而不是简单的第一个字符串。 在代码中，这是通过自定义编写的函数arrayStrLenMin()实现的。
- 可以显着降低迭代次数，但函数 arrayStrLenMin() 本身可能会导致（或多或少）迭代。
- 仅从数组中第一个字符串的长度开始似乎很笨拙，但如果 arrayStrLenMin() 需要多次迭代，可能会变得有效。
以尽可能少的迭代获取数组中字符串的最大公共前缀 (PHP)
代码 + 广泛测试 + 备注：
function arrayStrLenMin ($arr, $strictMode = false, $forLoop = false) {
$errArrZeroLength = -1; // Return value for error: Array is empty
$errOtherType = -2; // Return value for error: Found other type (than string in array)
$errStrNone = -3; // Return value for error: No strings found (in array)
$arrLength = count($arr);
if ($arrLength <= 0 ) { return $errArrZeroLength; }
$cur = 0;
foreach ($arr as $key => $val) {
if (is_string($val)) {
$min = strlen($val);
$strFirstFound = $key;
// echo("Key\tLength / Notification / Error\n");
// echo("$key\tFound first string member at key with length: $min!\n");
break;
}
else if ($strictMode) { return $errOtherType; } // At least 1 type other than string was found.
}
if (! isset($min)) { return $errStrNone; } // No string was found in array.
// SpeedRatio of foreach/for is approximately 2/1 as dicussed at:
// http://juliusbeckmann.de/blog/php-foreach-vs-while-vs-for-the-loop-battle.html
// If $strFirstFound is found within the first 1/SpeedRatio (=0.5) of the array, "foreach" is faster!
if (! $forLoop) {
foreach ($arr as $key => $val) {
if (is_string($val)) {
$cur = strlen($val);
// echo("$key\t$cur\n");
if ($cur == 0) { return $cur; } // 0 is the shortest possible string, so we can abort here.
if ($cur < $min) { $min = $cur; }
}
// else { echo("$key\tNo string!\n"); }
}
}
// If $strFirstFound is found after the first 1/SpeedRatio (=0.5) of the array, "for" is faster!
else {
for ($i = $strFirstFound + 1; $i < $arrLength; $i++) {
if (is_string($arr[$i])) {
$cur = strlen($arr[$i]);
// echo("$i\t$cur\n");
if ($cur == 0) { return $cur; } // 0 is the shortest possible string, so we can abort here.
if ($cur < $min) { $min = $cur; }
}
// else { echo("$i\tNo string!\n"); }
}
}
return $min;
}
function strCommonPrefixByStr($arr, $strFindShortestFirst = false) {
$arrLength = count($arr);
if ($arrLength < 2) { return false; }
// Determine loop length
/// Find shortest string in array: Can bring down iterations dramatically, but the function arrayStrLenMin() itself can cause ( more or less) iterations.
if ($strFindShortestFirst) { $end = arrayStrLenMin($arr, true); }
/// Simply start with length of first string in array: Seems quite clumsy, but may turn out effective, if arrayStrLenMin() needs many iterations.
else { $end = strlen($arr[0]); }
for ($i = 1; $i <= $end + 1; $i++) {
// Grab the part from 0 up to $i
$commonStrMax = substr($arr[0], 0, $i);
echo("Match: $i\t$commonStrMax\n");
// Loop through all the values in array, and compare if they match
foreach ($arr as $key => $str) {
echo(" Str: $key\t$str\n");
// Didn't match, return the part that did match
if ($commonStrMax != substr($str, 0, $i)) {
return substr($commonStrMax, 0, $i-1);
}
}
}
// Special case: No mismatch (hence no return) happened until loop end!
return $commonStrMax; // Thus entire first common string is the common prefix!
}
function strCommonPrefixByChar($arr, $strFindShortestFirst = false) {
$arrLength = count($arr);
if ($arrLength < 2) { return false; }
// Determine loop length
/// Find shortest string in array: Can bring down iterations dramatically, but the function arrayStrLenMin() itself can cause ( more or less) iterations.
if ($strFindShortestFirst) { $end = arrayStrLenMin($arr, true); }
/// Simply start with length of first string in array: Seems quite clumsy, but may turn out effective, if arrayStrLenMin() needs many iterations.
else { $end = strlen($arr[0]); }
for ($i = 0 ; $i <= $end + 1; $i++) {
// Grab char $i
$char = substr($arr[0], $i, 1);
echo("Match: $i\t"); echo(str_pad($char, $i+1, " ", STR_PAD_LEFT)); echo("\n");
// Loop through all the values in array, and compare if they match
foreach ($arr as $key => $str) {
echo(" Str: $key\t$str\n");
// Didn't match, return the part that did match
if ($char != $str[$i]) { // Same functionality as ($char != substr($str, $i, 1)). Same efficiency?
return substr($arr[0], 0, $i);
}
}
}
// Special case: No mismatch (hence no return) happened until loop end!
return substr($arr[0], 0, $end); // Thus entire first common string is the common prefix!
}
function strCommonPrefixByNeighbour($arr) {
$arrLength = count($arr);
if ($arrLength < 2) { return false; }
/// Get the common string prefix of the first 2 strings
$strCommonMax = strCommonPrefixByChar(array($arr[0], $arr[1]));
if ($strCommonMax === false) { return false; }
if ($strCommonMax == "") { return ""; }
$strCommonMaxLength = strlen($strCommonMax);
/// Now start looping from the 3rd string
echo("-----\n");
for ($i = 2; ($i < $arrLength) && ($strCommonMaxLength >= 1); $i++ ) {
echo(" STR: $i\t{$arr[$i]}\n");
/// Compare the maximum common string with the next neighbour
/*
//// Compare by char: Method unsuitable!
// Iterate from string end to string beginning
for ($ii = $strCommonMaxLength - 1; $ii >= 0; $ii--) {
echo("Match: $ii\t"); echo(str_pad($arr[$i][$ii], $ii+1, " ", STR_PAD_LEFT)); echo("\n");
// If you find the first mismatch from the end, break.
if ($arr[$i][$ii] != $strCommonMax[$ii]) {
$strCommonMaxLength = $ii - 1; break;
// BUT!!! We may falsely assume that the string from the first mismatch until the begining match! This new string neighbour string is completely "unexplored land", there might be differing chars closer to the beginning. This method is not suitable. Better use string comparison than char comparison.
}
}
*/
//// Compare by string
for ($ii = $strCommonMaxLength; $ii > 0; $ii--) {
echo("MATCH: $ii\t$strCommonMax\n");
if (substr($arr[$i],0,$ii) == $strCommonMax) {
break;
}
else {
$strCommonMax = substr($strCommonMax,0,$ii - 1);
$strCommonMaxLength--;
}
}
}
return substr($arr[0], 0, $strCommonMaxLength);
}
// Tests for finding the common prefix
/// Scenarios
$filesLeastInCommon = array (
"/Vol/1/aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa/a/1",
"/Vol/2/aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa/a/2",
"/Vol/1/aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa/b/1",
"/Vol/1/aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa/b/2",
"/Vol/2/aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa/b/c/1",
"/Vol/2/aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa/a/1",
);
$filesLessInCommon = array (
"/Vol/1/aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa/a/1",
"/Vol/1/aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa/a/2",
"/Vol/1/aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa/b/1",
"/Vol/1/aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa/b/2",
"/Vol/2/aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa/b/c/1",
"/Vol/2/aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa/a/1",
);
$filesMoreInCommon = array (
"/Voluuuuuuuuuuuuuumes/1/a/a/1",
"/Voluuuuuuuuuuuuuumes/1/a/a/2",
"/Voluuuuuuuuuuuuuumes/1/a/b/1",
"/Voluuuuuuuuuuuuuumes/1/a/b/2",
"/Voluuuuuuuuuuuuuumes/2/a/b/c/1",
"/Voluuuuuuuuuuuuuumes/2/a/a/1",
);
$sameDir = array (
"/Volumes/1/a/a/",
"/Volumes/1/a/a/aaaaa/2",
);
$sameFile = array (
"/Volumes/1/a/a/1",
"/Volumes/1/a/a/1",
);
$noCommonPrefix = array (
"/Volumes/1/a/a/",
"/Volumes/1/a/a/aaaaa/2",
"Net/1/a/a/aaaaa/2",
);
$longestLast = array (
"/Volumes/1/a/a/1",
"/Volumes/1/a/a/aaaaa/2",
);
$longestFirst = array (
"/Volumes/1/a/a/aaaaa/1",
"/Volumes/1/a/a/2",
);
$one = array ("/Volumes/1/a/a/aaaaa/1");
$empty = array ( );
// Test Results for finding the common prefix
/*
I tested my functions in many possible scenarios.
The results, the common prefixes, were always correct in all scenarios!
Just try a function call with your individual array!
Considering iteration efficiency, I also performed tests:
I put echo functions into the functions where iterations occur, and measured the number of CLI line output via:
php <script with strCommonPrefixByStr or strCommonPrefixByChar> | egrep "^ Str:" | wc -l GIVES TOTAL ITERATION SUM.
php <Script with strCommonPrefixByNeighbour> | egrep "^ Str:" | wc -l PLUS | egrep "^MATCH:" | wc -l GIVES TOTAL ITERATION SUM.
My hypothesis was proven:
strCommonPrefixByChar wins in situations where the strings have less in common in their beginning (=prefix).
strCommonPrefixByNeighbour wins where there is more in common in the prefixes.
*/
// Test Results Table
// Used Functions | Iteration amount | Remarks
// $result = (strCommonPrefixByStr($filesLessInCommon)); // 35
// $result = (strCommonPrefixByChar($filesLessInCommon)); // 35 // Same amount of iterations, but much fewer characters compared because ByChar instead of ByString!
// $result = (strCommonPrefixByNeighbour($filesLessInCommon)); // 88 + 42 = 130 // Loses in this category!
// $result = (strCommonPrefixByStr($filesMoreInCommon)); // 137
// $result = (strCommonPrefixByChar($filesMoreInCommon)); // 137 // Same amount of iterations, but much fewer characters compared because ByChar instead of ByString!
// $result = (strCommonPrefixByNeighbour($filesLeastInCommon)); // 12 + 4 = 16 // Far the winner in this category!
echo("Common prefix of all members:\n");
var_dump($result);
// Tests for finding the shortest string in array
/// Arrays
// $empty = array ();
// $noStrings = array (0,1,2,3.0001,4,false,true,77);
// $stringsOnly = array ("one","two","three","four");
// $mixed = array (0,1,2,3.0001,"four",false,true,"seven", 8888);
/// Scenarios
// I list them from fewest to most iterations, which is not necessarily equivalent to slowest to fastest!
// For speed consider the remarks in the code considering the Speed ratio of foreach/for!
//// Fewest iterations (immediate abort on "Found other type", use "for" loop)
// foreach( array($empty, $noStrings, $stringsOnly, $mixed) as $arr) {
// echo("NEW ANALYSIS:\n");
// echo("Result: " . arrayStrLenMin($arr, true, true) . "\n\n");
// }
/* Results:
NEW ANALYSIS:
Result: Array is empty!
NEW ANALYSIS:
Result: Found other type!
NEW ANALYSIS:
Key Length / Notification / Error
0 Found first string member at key with length: 3!
1 3
2 5
3 4
Result: 3
NEW ANALYSIS:
Result: Found other type!
*/
//// Fewer iterations (immediate abort on "Found other type", use "foreach" loop)
// foreach( array($empty, $noStrings, $stringsOnly, $mixed) as $arr) {
// echo("NEW ANALYSIS:\n");
// echo("Result: " . arrayStrLenMin($arr, true, false) . "\n\n");
// }
/* Results:
NEW ANALYSIS:
Result: Array is empty!
NEW ANALYSIS:
Result: Found other type!
NEW ANALYSIS:
Key Length / Notification / Error
0 Found first string member at key with length: 3!
0 3
1 3
2 5
3 4
Result: 3
NEW ANALYSIS:
Result: Found other type!
*/
//// More iterations (No immediate abort on "Found other type", use "for" loop)
// foreach( array($empty, $noStrings, $stringsOnly, $mixed) as $arr) {
// echo("NEW ANALYSIS:\n");
// echo("Result: " . arrayStrLenMin($arr, false, true) . "\n\n");
// }
/* Results:
NEW ANALYSIS:
Result: Array is empty!
NEW ANALYSIS:
Result: No strings found!
NEW ANALYSIS:
Key Length / Notification / Error
0 Found first string member at key with length: 3!
1 3
2 5
3 4
Result: 3
NEW ANALYSIS:
Key Length / Notification / Error
4 Found first string member at key with length: 4!
5 No string!
6 No string!
7 5
8 No string!
Result: 4
*/
//// Most iterations (No immediate abort on "Found other type", use "foreach" loop)
// foreach( array($empty, $noStrings, $stringsOnly, $mixed) as $arr) {
// echo("NEW ANALYSIS:\n");
// echo("Result: " . arrayStrLenMin($arr, false, false) . "\n\n");
// }
/* Results:
NEW ANALYSIS:
Result: Array is empty!
NEW ANALYSIS:
Result: No strings found!
NEW ANALYSIS:
Key Length / Notification / Error
0 Found first string member at key with length: 3!
0 3
1 3
2 5
3 4
Result: 3
NEW ANALYSIS:
Key Length / Notification / Error
4 Found first string member at key with length: 4!
0 No string!
1 No string!
2 No string!
3 No string!
4 4
5 No string!
6 No string!
7 5
8 No string!
Result: 4
*/