使用 python-telegram-bot 构建菜单的正确方法

Question

我与python-telegram-bot 合作，并尝试像BotFather 机器人那样构建一个嵌套菜单系统。例如，您有一个通用的机器人菜单

您可以在其中选择“编辑机器人”并获得新的相应菜单

带有返回上一个菜单的选项。

我尝试用代码来实现：

# main menu
def start(bot, update):
    menu_main = [[InlineKeyboardButton('Option 1', callback_data='m1')],
                 [InlineKeyboardButton('Option 2', callback_data='m2')],
                 [InlineKeyboardButton('Option 3', callback_data='m3')]]
    reply_markup = InlineKeyboardMarkup(menu_main)
    update.message.reply_text('Choose the option:', reply_markup=reply_markup)

# all other menus
def menu_actions(bot, update):
    query = update.callback_query

    if query.data == 'm1':
        # first submenu
        menu_1 = [[InlineKeyboardButton('Submenu 1-1', callback_data='m1_1')],
                  [InlineKeyboardButton('Submenu 1-2', callback_data='m1_2')]]
        reply_markup = InlineKeyboardMarkup(menu_1)
        bot.edit_message_text(chat_id=query.message.chat_id,
                              message_id=query.message.message_id,
                              text='Choose the option:',
                              reply_markup=reply_markup)
    elif query.data == 'm2':
        # second submenu
        # first submenu
        menu_2 = [[InlineKeyboardButton('Submenu 2-1', callback_data='m2_1')],
                  [InlineKeyboardButton('Submenu 2-2', callback_data='m2_2')]]
        reply_markup = InlineKeyboardMarkup(menu_2)
        bot.edit_message_text(chat_id=query.message.chat_id,
                              message_id=query.message.message_id,
                              text='Choose the option:',
                              reply_markup=reply_markup)
    elif query.data == 'm1_1':
        ...
    elif query.data == 'm1_2':
        ...
    # and so on for every callback_data option

...

# handlers
dispatcher.add_handler(CommandHandler('start', start))
dispatcher.add_handler(CallbackQueryHandler(menu_actions))

这段代码有效，但我觉得它有点不合理——构建一棵长 elif 树。

此外，我不知道如何为用户提供从二级菜单返回主菜单的选项（因为主菜单位于另一个处理程序中，我无法通过回调捕获它来自CallbackQueryHandler)。

所以问题是——构建这种菜单系统的最佳实践是什么？

Answer 1

您应该在CallbackQueryHandler 中使用参数pattern。为键盘和消息使用类或函数也是一件好事。
要返回主菜单，请将返回按钮添加到具有特定回调模式的子菜单。

请注意：您在菜单中使用edit_message_text。这意味着如果您从任何菜单中使用reply_text 方法调用start 函数，则不会发生任何事情。

带有函数的完整工作示例：

#!/usr/bin/env python3.8
from telegram.ext import Updater
from telegram.ext import CommandHandler, CallbackQueryHandler
from telegram import InlineKeyboardButton, InlineKeyboardMarkup
############################### Bot ############################################
def start(bot, update):
  bot.message.reply_text(main_menu_message(),
                         reply_markup=main_menu_keyboard())

def main_menu(bot, update):
  bot.callback_query.message.edit_text(main_menu_message(),
                          reply_markup=main_menu_keyboard())

def first_menu(bot, update):
  bot.callback_query.message.edit_text(first_menu_message(),
                          reply_markup=first_menu_keyboard())

def second_menu(bot, update):
  bot.callback_query.message.edit_text(second_menu_message(),
                          reply_markup=second_menu_keyboard())

def first_submenu(bot, update):
  pass

def second_submenu(bot, update):
  pass

def error(update, context):
    print(f'Update {update} caused error {context.error}')

############################ Keyboards #########################################
def main_menu_keyboard():
  keyboard = [[InlineKeyboardButton('Menu 1', callback_data='m1')],
              [InlineKeyboardButton('Menu 2', callback_data='m2')],
              [InlineKeyboardButton('Menu 3', callback_data='m3')]]
  return InlineKeyboardMarkup(keyboard)

def first_menu_keyboard():
  keyboard = [[InlineKeyboardButton('Submenu 1-1', callback_data='m1_1')],
              [InlineKeyboardButton('Submenu 1-2', callback_data='m1_2')],
              [InlineKeyboardButton('Main menu', callback_data='main')]]
  return InlineKeyboardMarkup(keyboard)

def second_menu_keyboard():
  keyboard = [[InlineKeyboardButton('Submenu 2-1', callback_data='m2_1')],
              [InlineKeyboardButton('Submenu 2-2', callback_data='m2_2')],
              [InlineKeyboardButton('Main menu', callback_data='main')]]
  return InlineKeyboardMarkup(keyboard)

############################# Messages #########################################
def main_menu_message():
  return 'Choose the option in main menu:'

def first_menu_message():
  return 'Choose the submenu in first menu:'

def second_menu_message():
  return 'Choose the submenu in second menu:'

############################# Handlers #########################################
updater = Updater('XXXXXXXXX:XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX', use_context=True)
updater.dispatcher.add_handler(CommandHandler('start', start))
updater.dispatcher.add_handler(CallbackQueryHandler(main_menu, pattern='main'))
updater.dispatcher.add_handler(CallbackQueryHandler(first_menu, pattern='m1'))
updater.dispatcher.add_handler(CallbackQueryHandler(second_menu, pattern='m2'))
updater.dispatcher.add_handler(CallbackQueryHandler(first_submenu, pattern='m1_1'))
updater.dispatcher.add_handler(CallbackQueryHandler(second_submenu, pattern='m2_1'))
updater.dispatcher.add_error_handler(error)

updater.start_polling()
################################################################################

抱歉，我在制表符中有两个空格。 :)

UPD：修复子菜单对象。

Answer 2

@dzNET 给出了很好的答案。但它在 V12 中不起作用，所以我稍微改变了一点

from telegram.ext import CommandHandler, CallbackQueryHandler
from telegram import InlineKeyboardButton, InlineKeyboardMarkup
############################### Bot ############################################
def start(update, context):
  update.message.reply_text(main_menu_message(),
                            reply_markup=main_menu_keyboard())

def main_menu(update,context):
  query = update.callback_query
  query.answer()
  query.edit_message_text(
                        text=main_menu_message(),
                        reply_markup=main_menu_keyboard())

def first_menu(update,context):
  query = update.callback_query
  query.answer()
  query.edit_message_text(
                        text=first_menu_message(),
                        reply_markup=first_menu_keyboard())

def second_menu(update,context):
  query = update.callback_query
  query.answer()
  query.edit_message_text(
                        text=second_menu_message(),
                        reply_markup=second_menu_keyboard())

# and so on for every callback_data option
def first_submenu(bot, update):
  pass

def second_submenu(bot, update):
  pass

############################ Keyboards #########################################
def main_menu_keyboard():
  keyboard = [[InlineKeyboardButton('Option 1', callback_data='m1')],
              [InlineKeyboardButton('Option 2', callback_data='m2')],
              [InlineKeyboardButton('Option 3', callback_data='m3')]]
  return InlineKeyboardMarkup(keyboard)

def first_menu_keyboard():
  keyboard = [[InlineKeyboardButton('Submenu 1-1', callback_data='m1_1')],
              [InlineKeyboardButton('Submenu 1-2', callback_data='m1_2')],
              [InlineKeyboardButton('Main menu', callback_data='main')]]
  return InlineKeyboardMarkup(keyboard)

def second_menu_keyboard():
  keyboard = [[InlineKeyboardButton('Submenu 2-1', callback_data='m2_1')],
              [InlineKeyboardButton('Submenu 2-2', callback_data='m2_2')],
              [InlineKeyboardButton('Main menu', callback_data='main')]]
  return InlineKeyboardMarkup(keyboard)

############################# Messages #########################################
def main_menu_message():
  return 'Choose the option in main menu:'

def first_menu_message():
  return 'Choose the submenu in first menu:'

def second_menu_message():
  return 'Choose the submenu in second menu:'

############################# Handlers #########################################
updater = Updater('YOUR_TOKEN_HERE', use_context=True)

updater.dispatcher.add_handler(CommandHandler('start', start))
updater.dispatcher.add_handler(CallbackQueryHandler(main_menu, pattern='main'))
updater.dispatcher.add_handler(CallbackQueryHandler(first_menu, pattern='m1'))
updater.dispatcher.add_handler(CallbackQueryHandler(second_menu, pattern='m2'))
updater.dispatcher.add_handler(CallbackQueryHandler(first_submenu,
                                                    pattern='m1_1'))
updater.dispatcher.add_handler(CallbackQueryHandler(second_submenu,
                                                    pattern='m2_1'))

updater.start_polling()

再次感谢@dzNET