Distinct (dplyr) 效果不佳 - 基于标准的独特观察

Question

我有一些重复记录的数据，其中一些不应该存在（mark 和 recov 应该每个 band 只出现一次，recap 可以出现多次）。我想根据列 (variable=="mark") 中的某些值选择唯一的观察值 (band)，并保留来自 "recap" 和 "recov" 的其余数据。

我使用dyplr，将我的数据按波段分组，然后在variable=="mark"列时选择唯一记录，这是我的代码：

uniq <- df %>%group_by(band)  %>% distinct(variable=="mark")

我发现它运行不佳，在查找某些观察结果时，variable=="recap" 中的另一个值已被删除（例如：在band=113749924 中，缺少 1993 年的回顾值，band=113728509 中的情况相同是否缺少概括值）

这是一个数据示例：

structure(list(band = c(113728501L, 113728502L, 113728503L, 113728504L, 
113728505L, 113728505L, 113728506L, 113728506L, 113728507L, 113728508L, 
113728509L, 113728509L, 113728509L, 113728509L, 113728510L, 113728510L, 
113729709L, 113729709L, 113729709L, 113729710L, 113729711L, 113729712L, 
113729713L, 113729714L, 113729715L, 113729716L, 113729717L, 113729718L, 
113729719L, 113729720L, 113729720L, 113729721L, 113729722L, 113729723L, 
113729724L, 113729725L, 113729726L, 113729727L, 113729728L, 113729729L, 
113729730L, 113729731L, 113729732L, 113729733L, 113729733L, 113729733L, 
113729734L, 113729735L, 113729735L, 113729735L, 113729914L, 113729914L, 
113729914L, 113729914L, 113729915L, 113729916L, 113729917L, 113729918L, 
113729919L, 113729920L, 113729921L, 113729922L, 113729923L, 113729924L, 
113729925L, 113729926L, 113729927L, 113729928L, 113729929L, 113749923L, 
113749924L, 113749924L, 113749924L), variable = structure(c(1L, 
1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 3L, 1L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 2L, 1L, 
3L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 3L, 1L, 1L, 
1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 3L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 3L, 
2L, 1L, 1L, 2L, 2L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 
1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 3L, 2L), .Label = c("mark", "recap", 
"recov"), class = "factor"), year = c(1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 
1994L, 2012L, 1994L, 1999L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 2002L, 
2003L, 1994L, 1996L, 1994L, 2002L, 1998L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 
1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1995L, 
1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 
1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 2002L, 2001L, 1994L, 1994L, 1999L, 
1998L, 1994L, 1994L, 1999L, 2005L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 
1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 1994L, 
1994L, 1994L, 1991L, 1991L, 1994L, 1993L)), .Names = c("band", 
"variable", "year"), class = "data.frame", row.names = c(NA, 
-73L))

最后我想要类似的东西（例如 113749924）：

band      year variable
113749924 1991 mark
113749924 1993 recap
113749924 1994 recov

您能帮我找出问题所在，或者建议我一个替代代码吗？

非常感谢！

Answer 1

一种选择是group_by'band'，filter'variable' 为'mark'的行，获取distinct 行，然后将其绑定（bind_rows）与filtered “变量”不是“标记”的数据集。

df %>% 
 group_by(band) %>% 
 filter(variable=="mark") %>% 
 ungroup() %>%
 distinct() %>%
 bind_rows(., filter(df, variable!="mark")) %>%
 arrange(band) %>%
 data.frame
       band variable year
1  113728501     mark 1994
2  113728502     mark 1994
3  113728503     mark 1994
4  113728504     mark 1994
5  113728505     mark 1994
6  113728505    recov 2012
7  113728506     mark 1994
8  113728506    recap 1999
9  113728507     mark 1994
10 113728508     mark 1994
11 113728509     mark 1994  ###only one mark.
12 113728509    recap 2002
13 113728509    recap 2003
14 113728510     mark 1994
15 113728510    recap 1996
16 113729709     mark 1994
17 113729709    recov 2002
18 113729709    recap 1998
19 113729710     mark 1994
20 113729711     mark 1994
21 113729712     mark 1994
22 113729713     mark 1994
23 113729714     mark 1994
24 113729715     mark 1994
25 113729716     mark 1994
26 113729717     mark 1994
27 113729718     mark 1994
28 113729719     mark 1994
29 113729720     mark 1994
30 113729720    recov 1995
31 113729721     mark 1994
32 113729722     mark 1994
33 113729723     mark 1994
34 113729724     mark 1994
35 113729725     mark 1994
36 113729726     mark 1994
37 113729727     mark 1994
38 113729728     mark 1994
39 113729729     mark 1994
40 113729730     mark 1994
41 113729731     mark 1994
42 113729732     mark 1994
43 113729733     mark 1994
44 113729733    recov 2002
45 113729733    recap 2001
46 113729734     mark 1994
47 113729735     mark 1994
48 113729735    recov 1999
49 113729735    recap 1998
50 113729914     mark 1994
51 113729914    recap 1999
52 113729914    recap 2005
53 113729915     mark 1994
54 113729916     mark 1994
55 113729917     mark 1994
56 113729918     mark 1994
57 113729919     mark 1994
58 113729920     mark 1994
59 113729921     mark 1994
60 113729922     mark 1994
61 113729923     mark 1994
62 113729924     mark 1994
63 113729925     mark 1994
64 113729926     mark 1994
65 113729927     mark 1994
66 113729928     mark 1994
67 113729929     mark 1994
68 113749923     mark 1991
69 113749924     mark 1991
70 113749924    recov 1994
71 113749924    recap 1993

---

或者另一种选择是group_by 'band' 和 'variable'，然后创建一个逻辑条件，其中row_number() 大于 1 并且 'variable' 是 'mark'，否定它（@987654329 @) 和 filter 行。

df %>% 
    group_by(band, variable) %>% 
    filter(!(row_number() >1 & variable =="mark"))