【问题标题】:Moving from state to state in this automaton via HashMap通过 HashMap 在这个自动机中从一个状态移动到另一个状态
【发布时间】:2010-12-24 21:41:02
【问题描述】:

我正在使用这种方法在这个自动机模拟器上从一个状态移动到下一个状态:

public void processString (String string){


StringBuilder stepString= new StringBuilder (string);


int actualStateIntIndex;





 System.out.println("THE FOUND INITIAL ONE IS "+ theInitialStateIntIndex);


   State firstState = allStates.get(theInitialStateIntIndex);

  actualState = firstState;

   while (stepString.length()>0){

       Character characterToProcess = stepString.charAt(0);
       stepString.deleteCharAt(0);

       State nextState;
       nextState = ((State)actualState.get(characterToProcess)); // pasa al siguiente State
   actualState = nextState;

   actualStateIntIndex=allStates.indexOf(actualState);


   System.out.println("the actual state for " + stepString + " is " + actualStateIntIndex);

   if ((actualState.isFinal==true) && (stepString.length()==0))
      {
          System.out.println("THE STRING " + string + " IS ACCEPTED AT STATE " + actualStateIntIndex );

      }

   else if (stepString.length()==0 && (actualState.isFinal==false)){
          System.out.println("THE STRING " + string + " IS REJECTED AT STATE " + actualStateIntIndex);

      }

   }

}

这里:

State nextState;
nextState = ((State)actualState.get(characterToProcess)); 

我可能做错了什么,但我不明白。

自动机总是卡在状态 0,虽然 StringBuilder 正在正确处理,为什么?

这是完整的代码:

       package afd;

        import java.io.*;
        import java.util.*;

        /**
         *
         * @author Administrator
         */
        public class Main {

        /**
         * @param args the command line arguments
         */
        public static void main(String[] args) throws IOException {
            // TODO code application logic here

            FileReader fr = new FileReader("E://Documents and Settings//Administrator//My Documents//NetBeansProjects//AFD//src//afd//dfa.in");


            BufferedReader br = new BufferedReader(fr);

            String firstLine= br.readLine();


            String [] firstLineSplitted = firstLine.split(" ");

            /*debug*/
            //System.out.println("firstLine is " + firstLine);

            int numberOfTestCases = Integer.parseInt(firstLine);

            for (int indexOfTestCases =0; indexOfTestCases < numberOfTestCases; indexOfTestCases++  ){

                int aux;
                System.out.println("Case Number " +  (aux = indexOfTestCases+1));

                String caseStartLine = br.readLine();

                /*debug*/
                //System.out.println("caseStarLine is " + caseStartLine);
                String [] caseStartLineSplitted = caseStartLine.split(" ");

                int numberOfStates;
                int numberOfAlphabetSymbols;
                int numberOfFinalStates;


                numberOfStates = Integer.parseInt(caseStartLineSplitted[0]);

                numberOfAlphabetSymbols = Integer.parseInt(caseStartLineSplitted[1]);

                numberOfFinalStates = Integer.parseInt(caseStartLineSplitted[2]);




                Automaton automaton = new Automaton();


                automaton.setAllStates(numberOfStates);

      //          automaton.size = numberOfStates;
     //           automaton.numberOfAlphabetSymbols = numberOfAlphabetSymbols;
     //           automaton.numberOfFinalStates = numberOfFinalStates;
                //Automaton a = new Automaton(numberOfStates);


                String alphabetLine = br.readLine();
                System.out.println("alphabetLine is " + alphabetLine);

                automaton.setAlphabet (alphabetLine);

    //            automaton.alphabetSymbols =new StringBuffer(alphabetLine);

                for (int indexOfStates = 0; indexOfStates < numberOfStates; indexOfStates++){

                      String transitionsLine = br.readLine();
                       /*debug*/
                       System.out.println("for the state " + indexOfStates + " transitionsLine is " + transitionsLine);

                       automaton.setTransitions(indexOfStates,transitionsLine);

                      /*String [] ijLineSplitted = ijLine.split(" ");

                      int i = Integer.parseInt(ijLineSplitted[0]);
                      int j = Integer.parseInt(ijLineSplitted[1]);
                        */

                }

                String finalStatesLine = br.readLine();
                /*debug*/
                System.out.println("finalStatesLine is " + finalStatesLine);
                String finalStatesLineSplitted [] = finalStatesLine.split(" ");

                automaton.markFinalStates(finalStatesLineSplitted);



                String initialStateAndNumberOfStringsLine = br.readLine();

                /*debug*/
                //System.out.println("initialStateAndNumberOfStringsLine  is " +initialStateAndNumberOfStringsLine);
                String [] splittedInitialStateLine = initialStateAndNumberOfStringsLine.split(" ");

                int initialState = Integer.parseInt(splittedInitialStateLine[0]);
                int numberOfStrings = Integer.parseInt(splittedInitialStateLine[1]);

                automaton.markInitialState(initialState);

                for (int stringIndex =0; stringIndex<numberOfStrings; stringIndex++){

                     String stringToProcess = br.readLine();
                     /*debug*/
                System.out.println("stringToProcess is " + stringToProcess);

                    automaton.processString(stringToProcess);


                }


             }
            }







    }


    class State extends HashMap<Character, State>{

    boolean isFinal;
    boolean isInitial;
    int stateId;

    State () {
        isInitial=false;
        isFinal = false;

        }

    public boolean equals (Object o){




        boolean isEqual = false;

        State compare = (State)o;

        if ((compare.stateId)==this.stateId)
        {

            return true;
        }

        return isEqual;

    }

    public int hashCode() {

        int theHashCode = stateId%7;

        return theHashCode;

    }


    }

      class Automaton{
         List <State> allStates;
        //private List<State> finalStates;
         int  theInitialStateIntIndex;
         State actualState;
          char [] alphabet;




        Automaton() {


            allStates = new ArrayList<State>();


        }public void setAllStates (int numberOfStates)  {

        for (int i =0; i <numberOfStates; i++) {

            State newState = new State();
            newState.stateId = i;
            allStates.add(newState);

         }

    }


    public void setAlphabet (String alphabetLine){

        alphabet = alphabetLine.toCharArray();




    }

    public void markFinalStates (String [] finalStates){

        for (int index =0; index<finalStates.length; index++) {

            int aFinalStateId = Integer.parseInt(finalStates[index]);

            State aFinalState = allStates.get(aFinalStateId);
            aFinalState.isFinal = true;
            allStates.add(aFinalStateId, aFinalState);


            /*DEBUG*/
            aFinalState = allStates.get(aFinalStateId);
            if ((aFinalState.isFinal)==true)
            System.out.println("THE STATE " + aFinalStateId + " IS MARKED AS FINAL");

        }

    }

    public void markInitialState (int initialStateId) {

            State theInitialState = allStates.get(initialStateId);
            theInitialState.isInitial=true;
            allStates.add(initialStateId, theInitialState);

            theInitialStateIntIndex = initialStateId;

            /*DEBUG*/

            System.out.println("THE INITIAL STATE ID IS " + initialStateId);

            theInitialState = allStates.get(initialStateId);
            if ((theInitialState.isInitial)==true)
            System.out.println("THE STATE " + initialStateId + " IS MARKED AS INITIAL");

    }


    public void setTransitions(int stateId, String transitionsLine){


            State theOneToChange = allStates.get(stateId);

            String [] statesToReachStringSplitted = transitionsLine.split(" ");

            for (int symbolIndex=0; symbolIndex<statesToReachStringSplitted.length;symbolIndex++){

                int reachedState= Integer.parseInt(statesToReachStringSplitted[symbolIndex]);

                theOneToChange.put(alphabet[symbolIndex],allStates.get(reachedState));

                System.out.println("THE STATE " + stateId + " REACHES THE STATE " + reachedState + " WITH THE SYMBOL " + alphabet[symbolIndex]);

            }

            allStates.add(stateId, theOneToChange);

    }


    public int findInitialState(){


        int index =0;

       cycle: for (; index<allStates.size(); index++){

            State s = allStates.get(index);

            if (s.isInitial==true) {

                break cycle;



           }
        } return index;

}



    public void processString (String string)
    {


        StringBuilder stepString= new StringBuilder (string);


        int actualStateIntIndex;



       System.out.println("THE FOUND INITIAL ONE IS "+ theInitialStateIntIndex);


       State firstState = allStates.get(theInitialStateIntIndex);

      actualState = firstState;

       while (stepString.length()>0){

           Character characterToProcess = stepString.charAt(0);
           stepString.deleteCharAt(0);

           State nextState;
           nextState = ((State)actualState.get(characterToProcess)); // pasa al siguiente State

           actualState = nextState;

           actualStateIntIndex=allStates.indexOf(actualState);


           System.out.println("the actual state for " + stepString + " is " + actualStateIntIndex);

           if ((actualState.isFinal==true) && (stepString.length()==0))
              {
                  System.out.println("THE STRING " + string + " IS ACCEPTED AT STATE " + actualStateIntIndex );

              }

           else if (stepString.length()==0 && (actualState.isFinal==false)){
                  System.out.println("THE STRING " + string + " IS REJECTED AT STATE " + actualStateIntIndex);

              }

           }



       }




    }

这是输入文件:

4
3 2 1
ab
1 0
2 0
2 0
2
0 3
abaa
aab
aba
3 3 2
ade
0 1 2
1 2 0
2 1 0
1 2
2 2
a
de
3 2 1
ab
1 0
2 0
2 0
2
0 3
abaa
aab
aba
3 3 2
ade
0 1 2
1 2 0
2 1 0
1 2
2 2
a
de

编辑:这里我将解释这个输入文件的格式

第一行代表测试用例的数量。

每个测试用例以 3 个整数开头,第一个是自动机的状态数,接下来是字母表中的符号数,然后是最终状态数。

下一行是字母表。符号一起出现。

然后,行数等于描述转换函数的状态数。这组线的第一行表示自动机 (qo) 中第一个状态的转换函数,第一个元素表示当字母表中的第一个符号进入该状态时达到的状态,依此类推。我无法从原始问题陈述中理解这一点。这是我看到的最简单的方法:

线条:

1 0
2 0
2 0

等于:

            AlphabetSymbol0        AlphabetSymbol1
State0         State1                State0
State1         State2                State0
State2         State2                State0

然后有一行说明自动机的最终状态。

然后是一行,说明哪个是初始状态以及将出现多少输入字符串。

然后是输入字符串的行。

这个程序的输出应该是:

C

ase Number 1
alphabetLine is ab
for the state 0 transitionsLine is 1 0
THE STATE 0 REACHES THE STATE 1 WITH THE SYMBOL a
THE STATE 0 REACHES THE STATE 0 WITH THE SYMBOL b
for the state 1 transitionsLine is 2 0
THE STATE 1 REACHES THE STATE 2 WITH THE SYMBOL a
THE STATE 1 REACHES THE STATE 0 WITH THE SYMBOL b
for the state 2 transitionsLine is 2 0
THE STATE 2 REACHES THE STATE 2 WITH THE SYMBOL a
THE STATE 2 REACHES THE STATE 0 WITH THE SYMBOL b
finalStatesLine is 2
THE STATE 2 IS MARKED AS FINAL
THE INITIAL STATE ID IS 0
THE STATE 0 IS MARKED AS INITIAL
stringToProcess is abaa
THE FOUND INITIAL ONE IS 0
the actual state for baa is 0
the actual state for aa is 0
the actual state for a is 0
the actual state for  is 0
**THE STRING abaa IS ACCEPTED AT STATE 2**
stringToProcess is aab
THE FOUND INITIAL ONE IS 0
the actual state for ab is 0
the actual state for b is 0
the actual state for  is 0
**THE STRING aab IS REJECTED AT STATE 0**
stringToProcess is aba
THE FOUND INITIAL ONE IS 0
the actual state for ba is 0
the actual state for a is 0
the actual state for  is 0
**THE STRING aba IS ACCEPTED AT STATE 1**
Case Number 2
alphabetLine is ade
for the state 0 transitionsLine is 0 1 2
THE STATE 0 REACHES THE STATE 0 WITH THE SYMBOL a
THE STATE 0 REACHES THE STATE 1 WITH THE SYMBOL d
THE STATE 0 REACHES THE STATE 2 WITH THE SYMBOL e
for the state 1 transitionsLine is 1 2 0
THE STATE 1 REACHES THE STATE 1 WITH THE SYMBOL a
THE STATE 1 REACHES THE STATE 2 WITH THE SYMBOL d
THE STATE 1 REACHES THE STATE 0 WITH THE SYMBOL e
for the state 2 transitionsLine is 2 1 0
THE STATE 2 REACHES THE STATE 2 WITH THE SYMBOL a
THE STATE 2 REACHES THE STATE 1 WITH THE SYMBOL d
THE STATE 2 REACHES THE STATE 0 WITH THE SYMBOL e
finalStatesLine is 1 2
THE STATE 1 IS MARKED AS FINAL
THE STATE 2 IS MARKED AS FINAL
THE INITIAL STATE ID IS 2
THE STATE 2 IS MARKED AS INITIAL
stringToProcess is a
THE FOUND INITIAL ONE IS 2
the actual state for  is 0
**THE STRING a IS ACCEPTED AT STATE 2** 
stringToProcess is de
THE FOUND INITIAL ONE IS 2
the actual state for e is 0
the actual state for  is 0
**THE STRING de IS REJECTED AT STATE 0** 

我错了所有用粗体写的行。

我明白了:

Case Number 1

THE STRING abaa IS ACCEPTED AT STATE 0
THE STRING aab IS ACCEPTED AT STATE 0
THE STRING aba IS ACCEPTED AT STATE 0


Case Number 2
THE STRING a IS ACCEPTED AT STATE 0
THE STRING de IS ACCEPTED AT STATE 0

我的自动机接受一切并卡在状态 0,为什么?

【问题讨论】:

  • 您提供的代码无法编译...有些东西丢失了。但是,你能告诉我有多少个状态,stateID 的值是否重要,或者它可以是什么?
  • 已修复。每个测试用例有3个状态,有两个测试用例。

标签: java hashmap automaton


【解决方案1】:

我很确定问题在于 State 需要覆盖 .equals(Object) 和 .hashCode()。我相信 allStates 是 List&lt;State&gt; 并且在该 List 上调用 get(State) equals 必须被覆盖。

【讨论】:

  • 是的,allStates 是一个 ArrayList。我没有使用 Collections 的经验,这对 equals() 和 hashCode() 的覆盖应该如何?
  • 我修复了代码以使其能够编译。我不明白为什么要在这里覆盖 equals 和 hasCode 。请详细说明一下好吗?
  • 当在集合中查找对象时,它会调用 .equals 方法。您可以认为来自 Object 的 .equals 当且仅当两个对象相同时才返回 true(本质上是 o == o,或物理相等)。要检查逻辑相等(数据成员是否相同),您需要覆盖 .equals。当您覆盖 .equals 时,您必须覆盖地图中使用的 .hashCode() 以及 .equals。
【解决方案2】:

好吧,一方面processState 方法似乎根本没有更新自动机的currentState 字段。事实上,你似乎没有在任何地方修改它。

不过,如果你能更好地解释你正在做的事情,那将会有所帮助。尽管我们不知道状态 0 是什么或如何检测到这种情况,但您刚刚转储了许多未注释的源代码并说“它卡在状态 0”。我猜测 currentState 指向这一点,尽管 State 实例也没有数字,所以很难知道从哪里开始分析这个......

至少,提供两点信息(虽然更多会更好):

  1. 您希望看到的表示成功的字段值/输出,以及您当前看到的内容(明确关于特定字段的具体值);
  2. 您希望这些字段在什么地方更新以及在什么条件下更新。

【讨论】:

  • 谢谢,我已根据您的建议修改了代码和问题。我从您的链接中阅读了有关 equals 和 hashCode 的信息,但我仍然不知道如何使它们工作,因此自动机不会卡在 state0 上。
猜你喜欢
  • 2022-09-25
  • 1970-01-01
  • 2021-04-26
  • 1970-01-01
  • 2023-03-31
  • 2013-06-28
  • 2020-06-22
  • 1970-01-01
  • 1970-01-01
相关资源
最近更新 更多