Perforce resolve 无法正确处理重命名

Question

假设我们在仓库中有这些流

 main
 /  \
A    B

所有这些流都有以下文件：

01.txt：01

02.txt：02

我从 A 提交这两个变更列表。

#1：p4 move 01.txt legacy_01.txt

#2：p4 move 02.txt 01.txt

然后我将这些更改列表复制到主目录。 至此，main 的文件和预期的一样。

legacy_01.txt：01

01.txt：02

但是，当我合并到 B 时，问题就出现了。 经过一些自动解析（不管你已经 p4 resolve 然后盲目接受所有，甚至使用 p4v 的安全不合并自动解析），文件变成：

legacy_01.txt：02

（其他文件被删除）

问题更大，因为即使您使用了 p4v 的安全自动解析，它也会发生。 当然，我可以仔细调整解析顺序来防止这种情况，但为什么这是默认值？

Answer 1

tl;dr：将文件重命名到彼此的位置，然后压缩生成的更改列表是有问题的。

复制到 main 时出现问题。

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 copy A/... main/...
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/02.txt#1 - delete from //stream/main/seongchan-test/A/02.txt#1,#2
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/01.txt#1 - sync/integrate from //stream/main/seongchan-test/A/01.txt#1,#3
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/legacy_01.txt#1 - branch/sync from //stream/main/seongchan-test/A/legacy_01.txt#1

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 opened
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/01.txt#1 - integrate default change (text)
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/02.txt#1 - delete default change (text)
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/legacy_01.txt#1 - branch default change (text)

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 resolved
c:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test\main\01.txt - copy from //stream/main/seongchan-test/A/01.txt#1,#3
c:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test\main\02.txt - delete from //stream/main/seongchan-test/A/02.txt#1,#2
c:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test\main\legacy_01.txt - branch from //stream/main/seongchan-test/A/legacy_01.txt#1

请注意，没有任何文件是为“移动”打开的——01->legacy_01 和 02->01 操作的顺序（由以特定顺序发生的 move/add 和 move/delete 操作表示）已经由于这两个变更列表的“挤压”而丢失！

这最终会混淆后续的合并/解析；它试图一次完成所有操作，并且它最大的努力是将02->01 和01->legacy_01 组合成02->legacy_01，考虑到这些操作最初发生的顺序，这实际上并不是您想要的。

有一个 undoc 设置会在 copy 操作期间向您发出警告：

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 configure set dm.copy.movewarn=1
For server 'any', configuration variable 'dm.copy.movewarn' set to '1'

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 copy A/... main/...
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/02.txt#1 - delete from //stream/main/seongchan-test/A/02.txt#1,#2
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/01.txt#1 - sync/integrate from //stream/main/seongchan-test/A/01.txt#1,#3
... can't open as move/add because a file already exists in this location.
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/legacy_01.txt#1 - branch/sync from //stream/main/seongchan-test/A/legacy_01.txt#1
... can't open as move/add because //stream/main/seongchan-test/main/01.txt is not being opened for delete.
Some files couldn't be opened for move.  Try copying from @268 instead?

如果我接受错误消息的建议，我最终会分阶段进行复制，每个阶段都会复制move 操作之一：

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 revert ...
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/legacy_01.txt#none - was branch, deleted
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/01.txt#1 - was integrate, reverted
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/02.txt#1 - was delete, reverted

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 copy A/...@268 main/...
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/01.txt#1 - move/delete from //stream/main/seongchan-test/A/01.txt#1,#2
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/legacy_01.txt#1 - move/add/sync from //stream/main/seongchan-test/A/legacy_01.txt#1

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 submit -d "copy from A@268"
Submitting change 271.
Locking 2 files ...
move/delete //stream/main/seongchan-test/main/01.txt#2
move/add //stream/main/seongchan-test/main/legacy_01.txt#1
Change 271 submitted.

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 copy A/... main/...
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/02.txt#1 - move/delete from //stream/main/seongchan-test/A/02.txt#1,#2
//stream/main/seongchan-test/main/01.txt#2 - move/add/sync from //stream/main/seongchan-test/A/01.txt#3

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 submit -d "finish copy from A"
Submitting change 272.
Locking 2 files ...
move/add //stream/main/seongchan-test/main/01.txt#3
move/delete //stream/main/seongchan-test/main/02.txt#2
Change 272 submitted.

现在，当我们合并到 B 时，它会看到这两个动作并尝试解决它们——而不是像 copy 那样尝试“挤压”它们，resolve 会警告你你不能同时做这两个：

c:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test\B\02.txt - resolving move to //stream/main/seongchan-test/B/01.txt
//Samwise-dvcs-1509687817/seongchan-test/B/01.txt - can't move to an existing file

此时的修复与之前类似；您必须一次备份并执行一个更改列表（在两者之间提交）才能成功合并。

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 merge main/...@271 B/...
//stream/main/seongchan-test/B/01.txt#1 - integrate from //stream/main/seongchan-test/main/legacy_01.txt#1 (remapped from //stream/main/seongchan-test/B/legacy_01.txt)
... must resolve content from //stream/main/seongchan-test/main/legacy_01.txt#1
... must resolve move to //stream/main/seongchan-test/B/legacy_01.txt

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 resolve -as
c:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test\B\01.txt - merging //stream/main/seongchan-test/main/legacy_01.txt#1
Diff chunks: 0 yours + 0 theirs + 0 both + 0 conflicting
//Samwise-dvcs-1509687817/seongchan-test/B/01.txt - copy from //stream/main/seongchan-test/main/legacy_01.txt
c:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test\B\01.txt - resolving move to //stream/main/seongchan-test/B/legacy_01.txt
//stream/main/seongchan-test/B/legacy_01.txt - moved from //stream/main/seongchan-test/B/01.txt

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 submit -d "merge from main@271"
Submitting change 273.
Locking 2 files ...
move/delete //stream/main/seongchan-test/B/01.txt#2
move/add //stream/main/seongchan-test/B/legacy_01.txt#1
Change 273 submitted.

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 merge main/... B/...
//stream/main/seongchan-test/B/02.txt#1 - integrate from //stream/main/seongchan-test/main/01.txt#3 (remapped from //stream/main/seongchan-test/B/01.txt)
... must resolve content from //stream/main/seongchan-test/main/01.txt#3
... must resolve move to //stream/main/seongchan-test/B/01.txt

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 resolve -as
c:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test\B\02.txt - merging //stream/main/seongchan-test/main/01.txt#3
Diff chunks: 0 yours + 0 theirs + 0 both + 0 conflicting
//Samwise-dvcs-1509687817/seongchan-test/B/02.txt - copy from //stream/main/seongchan-test/main/01.txt
c:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test\B\02.txt - resolving move to //stream/main/seongchan-test/B/01.txt
//stream/main/seongchan-test/B/01.txt - moved from //stream/main/seongchan-test/B/02.txt

C:\Perforce\test\seongchan-test>p4 submit -d "finish merge from main"
Submitting change 274.
Locking 2 files ...
move/add //stream/main/seongchan-test/B/01.txt#3
move/delete //stream/main/seongchan-test/B/02.txt#2
Change 274 submitted.

与复制一样，我们可以看到现在每个合并操作“重播”源的一个移动操作；它们必须一次发生一个，因为第二次合并需要将文件移动到第一次删除的路径中。