链表的基于范围的循环

Question

我有一个在嵌套链表上运行的函数。函数如下：

void DoLiana(void) {

    PlotPointer plot;
    TreePointer tree;

        plot = FirstPlot;
        while (plot != nullptr) {
            tree = plot->FirstTree;
            while (tree != nullptr) {
                if (tree->isLiana) {
                    if (tree->attachedTree == nullptr && TestForLianaAttach(plot, tree))
                    DoLianaAttachement(plot, tree);
                }
                tree = tree->next;
            }
            plot = plot->next;
        }    
}

因为这种类型的迭代在我的代码中多次发生，所以我正在寻找一种方法来使迭代更加紧凑和富有表现力。我读到在 C++11 中有基于范围的 for 循环迭代一个集合。这种结构是否适用于这种情况？还是有其他可能的方法来执行这些迭代？

Answer 1

要跟进Serge Ballesta's comment，您可以立即在此处使用香草for 循环，替换while 循环。所以你的示例代码会变成：

void DoLiana(void) {

    for (PlotPointer plot = FirstPlot; plot; plot = plot->next) { 
        for (TreePointer tree = plot->FirstTree; tree; tree = tree->next) {
            if (tree->isLiana && !tree->attachedTree && TestForLianaAttach(plot, tree)) {
                DoLianaAttachement(plot, tree);
            }
        }
    }
}

这会缩短代码，并增加局部性和可读性。如果这是一个优势，还可以保持与 C 的兼容性。

Answer 2

是的，您可以为此定义适当的函数。

因为 oyu 给出的细节很少。让我们做一些假设。

struct Tree
{
    bool  isLiana;
    void* attachedTree;
    Tree* next;
};

using TreePointer = Tree*;

struct Plot
{
    TreePointer FirstTree;
    Plot*       next;
};

using PlotPointer = Plot*;

bool TestForLianaAttach(PlotPointer, TreePointer);
void DoLianaAttachement(PlotPointer, TreePointer);

PlotPointer FirstPlot;

要使用指针，您需要为指针定义适当的 begin() 和 end() 方法。

NextIterator<Plot> begin(PlotPointer ptr)  {return make_NextIterator(ptr);}
NextIterator<Plot> end(PlotPointer)        {return make_NextIterator<Plot>();}

NextIterator<Tree> begin(TreePointer ptr)  {return make_NextIterator(ptr);}
NextIterator<Tree> end(TreePointer)        {return make_NextIterator<Tree>();}

基于范围的 for 查找可与您的类型一起使用的 begin() 和 end() 函数。现在标准具有默认的std::begin() 和std::end()，它们在传递的对象上调用begin() 和end() 方法。但是您可以提供自己的（如上）为您的类型/指针做一个特殊情况。

现在，由于您的指针使用p = p->next; 来推进，我们需要一个迭代器对象来完成这部分工作。在上面的代码中，我称之为NextIterator。比较容易定义。

template<typename T>
struct NextIterator
{
    T* p;

    NextIterator():       p(nullptr) {}
    NextIterator(T* ptr): p(ptr)     {}

    NextIterator& operator++(){p = p->next;return *this;}

    T const& operator*() const  {return *p;}
    T&       operator*()        {return *p;}
    T const* operator->() const {return p;}
    T*       operator->()       {return p;}

    bool operator==(NextIterator const& rhs) const {return p == rhs.p;}
    bool operator!=(NextIterator const& rhs) const {return p != rhs.p;}
};
template<typename T>
NextIterator<T> make_NextIterator(T* val)   {return NextIterator<T>(val);}
template<typename T>
NextIterator<T> make_NextIterator()         {return NextIterator<T>{};}

现在我们可以使用基于范围的 for 重写您的循环。

void DoLianaRange(void) {

        for(auto& plot: FirstPlot) {
            for(auto& tree: plot.FirstTree) {
                if (tree.isLiana) {
                    if (tree.attachedTree == nullptr && TestForLianaAttach(&plot, &tree))
                    DoLianaAttachement(&plot, &tree);
                }
            }
        }
}

原始版本进行比较。

void DoLiana(void) {

    PlotPointer plot;
    TreePointer tree;

        plot = FirstPlot;
        while (plot != nullptr) {
            tree = plot->FirstTree;
            while (tree != nullptr) {
                if (tree->isLiana) {
                    if (tree->attachedTree == nullptr && TestForLianaAttach(plot, tree))
                    DoLianaAttachement(plot, tree);
                }
                tree = tree->next;
            }
            plot = plot->next;
        }
}

或者您可以简单地使用标准 for 循环！

void DoLianaForLoop(void) {

        for (PlotPointer plot = FirstPlot; plot != nullptr; plot = plot->next) {
            for (TreePointer tree= plot->FirstTree; tree != nullptr; tree = tree->next) {
                if (tree->isLiana) {
                    if (tree->attachedTree == nullptr && TestForLianaAttach(plot, tree))
                    DoLianaAttachement(plot, tree);
                }
            }
        }
}

代码都在一个地方（按照正确的编译顺序）。

struct Tree
{
    bool  isLiana;
    void* attachedTree;
    Tree* next;
};

using TreePointer = Tree*;

struct Plot
{
    TreePointer FirstTree;
    Plot*       next;
};

using PlotPointer = Plot*;

template<typename T>
struct NextIterator
{
    T* p;

    NextIterator():       p(nullptr) {}
    NextIterator(T* ptr): p(ptr)     {}

    NextIterator& operator++(){p = p->next;return *this;}

    T const& operator*() const  {return *p;}
    T&       operator*()        {return *p;}
    T const* operator->() const {return p;}
    T*       operator->()       {return p;}

    bool operator==(NextIterator const& rhs) const {return p == rhs.p;}
    bool operator!=(NextIterator const& rhs) const {return p != rhs.p;}
};

template<typename T>
NextIterator<T> make_NextIterator(T* val)   {return NextIterator<T>(val);}
template<typename T>
NextIterator<T> make_NextIterator()         {return NextIterator<T>{};}

NextIterator<Plot> begin(PlotPointer ptr)  {return make_NextIterator(ptr);}
NextIterator<Plot> end(PlotPointer)        {return make_NextIterator<Plot>();}

NextIterator<Tree> begin(TreePointer ptr)  {return make_NextIterator(ptr);}
NextIterator<Tree> end(TreePointer)        {return make_NextIterator<Tree>();}

bool TestForLianaAttach(PlotPointer, TreePointer);
void DoLianaAttachement(PlotPointer, TreePointer);

PlotPointer FirstPlot;

void DoLianaRange(void) {

        for(auto& plot: FirstPlot) {
            for(auto& tree: plot.FirstTree) {
                if (tree.isLiana) {
                    if (tree.attachedTree == nullptr && TestForLianaAttach(&plot, &tree))
                    DoLianaAttachement(&plot, &tree);
                }
            }
        }
}
void DoLiana(void) {

    PlotPointer plot;
    TreePointer tree;

        plot = FirstPlot;
        while (plot != nullptr) {
            tree = plot->FirstTree;
            while (tree != nullptr) {
                if (tree->isLiana) {
                    if (tree->attachedTree == nullptr && TestForLianaAttach(plot, tree))
                    DoLianaAttachement(plot, tree);
                }
                tree = tree->next;
            }
            plot = plot->next;
        }
}