【问题标题】:Emmeans is reporting different estimates and CIs for marginal means if printed as data.frame如果打印为 data.frame,Emmeans 将报告边际均值的不同估计和置信区间
【发布时间】:2023-01-31 18:46:03
【问题描述】:

拟合 LMM 后,我使用 emmeans() 函数提取估计的边际均值、SE 和置信区间。但是,取决于我是直接提取均值,还是将估计值保存为数据框,它们的 SE 和置信区间会有所不同。任何见解将不胜感激。

示例(由于字符限制无法使用 dput 和提供原始数据):

> summary(model)
Linear mixed model fit by maximum likelihood . t-tests use Satterthwaite's method ['lmerModLmerTest']
Formula: asin(sqrt(r_index)) ~ year + prov_season + factor_month + group + prov_season * year * group + (1 | individual)

直接提取emmeans:

mm <- emmeans(model, pairwise ~ prov_season*year | group, at = list(year = c(1:8))) # extract estimates, sems and and CIs

> print(mm$emmeans)
group = naive:
 prov_season       year emmean     SE  df lower.CL upper.CL
 in                   1 0.0112 0.1587 309  -0.3011    0.324
 off                  1 0.0872 0.1768 378  -0.2604    0.435
 in                   2 0.0229 0.1437 253  -0.2600    0.306
 off                  2 0.1186 0.1577 313  -0.1916    0.429
 in                   3 0.0345 0.1305 203  -0.2228    0.292
 off                  3 0.1500 0.1405 247  -0.1268    0.427
 in                   4 0.0461 0.1199 162  -0.1906    0.283
 off                  4 0.1814 0.1261 189  -0.0674    0.430
 in                   5 0.0577 0.1125 136  -0.1647    0.280
 off                  5 0.2128 0.1155 148  -0.0155    0.441
 in                   6 0.0693 0.1090 125  -0.1465    0.285
 off                  6 0.2442 0.1098 128   0.0268    0.462
 in                   7 0.0810 0.1099 129  -0.1364    0.298
 off                  7 0.2756 0.1098 129   0.0584    0.493
 in                   8 0.0926 0.1149 149  -0.1345    0.320
 off                  8 0.3070 0.1154 151   0.0790    0.535

group = provisioned:
 prov_season       year emmean     SE  df lower.CL upper.CL
 in                   1 0.4076 0.0924 314   0.2258    0.589
 off                  1 0.2519 0.1043 413   0.0469    0.457
 in                   2 0.4422 0.0907 307   0.2638    0.621
 off                  2 0.2528 0.1000 381   0.0561    0.449
 in                   3 0.4768 0.0899 305   0.2999    0.654
 off                  3 0.2538 0.0970 355   0.0630    0.444
 in                   4 0.5114 0.0902 308   0.3339    0.689
 off                  4 0.2547 0.0952 337   0.0674    0.442
 in                   5 0.5461 0.0915 315   0.3659    0.726
 off                  5 0.2557 0.0949 329   0.0690    0.442
 in                   6 0.5807 0.0938 325   0.3961    0.765
 off                  6 0.2566 0.0959 331   0.0680    0.445
 in                   7 0.6153 0.0970 339   0.4245    0.806
 off                  7 0.2576 0.0983 342   0.0643    0.451
 in                   8 0.6499 0.1010 355   0.4512    0.849
 off                  8 0.2585 0.1019 361   0.0581    0.459

Results are averaged over the levels of: factor_month 
Degrees-of-freedom method: kenward-roger 
Results are given on the asin(sqrt(mu)) (not the response) scale. 
Confidence level used: 0.95 

emmeans as.data.frame() 的提取:

> as.data.frame(mm)
 group       prov_season       year contrast                             emmean      SE  df lower.CL upper.CL
 naive       in          1          .                                  0.011232 0.15872 309  -0.5897  0.61217
 naive       off         1          .                                  0.087219 0.17677 378  -0.5806  0.75500
 naive       in          2          .                                  0.022854 0.14365 253  -0.5225  0.56821
 naive       off         2          .                                  0.118613 0.15767 313  -0.4783  0.71550
 naive       in          3          .                                  0.034476 0.13049 203  -0.4628  0.53172
 naive       off         3          .                                  0.150007 0.14053 247  -0.3837  0.68374
 naive       in          4          .                                  0.046098 0.11986 162  -0.4128  0.50498
 naive       off         4          .                                  0.181401 0.12615 189  -0.2999  0.66275
 naive       in          5          .                                  0.057720 0.11249 136  -0.3749  0.49036
 naive       off         5          .                                  0.212795 0.11555 148  -0.2306  0.65616
 naive       in          6          .                                  0.069342 0.10904 125  -0.3511  0.48977
 naive       off         6          .                                  0.244189 0.10984 128  -0.1790  0.66738
 naive       in          7          .                                  0.080964 0.10988 129  -0.3423  0.50419
 naive       off         7          .                                  0.275583 0.10979 129  -0.1473  0.69850
 naive       in          8          .                                  0.092586 0.11491 149  -0.3483  0.53345
 naive       off         8          .                                  0.306977 0.11541 151  -0.1356  0.74957
 provisioned in          1          .                                  0.407628 0.09240 314   0.0578  0.75742
 provisioned off         1          .                                  0.251854 0.10425 413  -0.1416  0.64535
 provisioned in          2          .                                  0.442235 0.09067 307   0.0989  0.78555
 provisioned off         2          .                                  0.252805 0.10002 381  -0.1250  0.63063
 provisioned in          3          .                                  0.476842 0.08994 305   0.1363  0.81742
 provisioned off         3          .                                  0.253756 0.09698 355  -0.1128  0.62035
 provisioned in          4          .                                  0.511450 0.09023 308   0.1698  0.85310
 provisioned off         4          .                                  0.254708 0.09524 337  -0.1055  0.61493
 provisioned in          5          .                                  0.546057 0.09154 315   0.1995  0.89257
 provisioned off         5          .                                  0.255659 0.09488 329  -0.1033  0.61460
 provisioned in          6          .                                  0.580665 0.09382 325   0.2257  0.93566
 provisioned off         6          .                                  0.256610 0.09590 331  -0.1062  0.61941
 provisioned in          7          .                                  0.615272 0.09700 339   0.2484  0.98214
 provisioned off         7          .                                  0.257561 0.09827 342  -0.1141  0.62920
 provisioned in          8          .                                  0.649879 0.10101 355   0.2681  1.03170
 provisioned off         8          .                                  0.258513 0.10190 361  -0.1266  0.64363

【问题讨论】:

  • 请按照 r 标签页顶部的指南提供最少的可重现代码和输入。

标签: r linear-regression emmeans lmertest


【解决方案1】:

as.data.frame 默认情况下根据表中的对比和均值对置信区间进行 Bonferroni 校正。

您可以使用例如 adjust="none" 作为参数来更改此行为。

在这个问题的答案中有更多关于这种行为的细节(关于 p 值调整)。

Why is converting emmeans contrasts to a data.frame not reporting correct p-values?

很难预测对 p 值和置信区间 emmeans 进行了哪些调整,而且从文档中并不总是很明显,因此通常最好明确地控制它。

顺便说一句,即使您无法粘贴完整数据,制作一个小型可重现数据集来证明您的问题也很容易。

【讨论】:

    猜你喜欢
    • 2019-07-02
    • 1970-01-01
    • 2014-06-05
    • 1970-01-01
    • 1970-01-01
    • 2020-12-27
    • 1970-01-01
    • 1970-01-01
    • 1970-01-01
    相关资源
    最近更新 更多